John Jay Ct, New Windsor
- 2000 John Jay Ct Oates, Sandra E
- 2001 John Jay Ct O'Flaherty, Michele
- 2002 John Jay Ct Locicero, Jeannine A
- 2003 John Jay Ct Soto, Daisy
- 2004 John Jay Ct Linton, Claudette E
- 2005 John Jay Ct Marshall, Cynthia
- 2006 John Jay Ct D'Alessandro, Claude G
- 2007 John Jay Ct Minutolo , Nicholas
- 2008 John Jay Ct Huston, Tyler
- 2009 John Jay Ct Lissauer, Lawrence D
- 2010 John Jay Ct Albano, Silverio
- 2011 John Jay Ct Colon, Isaias
- 2012 John Jay Ct Appel , Mariela
- 2013 John Jay Ct Abusbeih, Isoda
- 2014 John Jay Ct Kane , Kelly
- 2015 John Jay Ct Posenato, Christina S
- 2016 John Jay Ct Ordonez, Giovanni A
- 2017 John Jay Ct D'Amico, Tara M
- 2018 John Jay Ct 250 Lake Street Properties,Llc
- 2019 John Jay Ct Damon, Gregg
- 2021 John Jay Ct Sherman, Christopher M