NY Property Records
5024 Avenue I
5024 Avenue I
Brooklyn · Kings County · 11234
01 · 1–2 FamilySold $190,000 · Apr 2026 ↗
Owner of record
OwnerCynthia Nicholas
Assessment · 2025 roll
Land assessed$12,840
Total assessed$51,300
Est. annual tax$8,540 (2027, excl. special districts)
Building
StyleOne Story (Permanent Living Quaters)
Year built1945
Living area1,196 sq ft
Lot
Size0.05 acres (GIS)
Frontage × depth23 × 100 ft
Lot sq ft2,300
Zoning
DistrictR5
FAR0.95 built · 1.5 max residential · 2.0 max facility
Zoning map23a
Recorded documents · 42
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jul 1, 2026
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Secretary Of Housing And Urban Development
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jul 1, 2026
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
$10
May 15, 2026
grantor/seller Estate Of Cynthia Nicholas; Interest Heir At Law, Cheryl Harrison To Her +1
grantee/buyer 135 Street Investors LLC
View on ACRIS ↗Show all 42
DEED
$190,000
May 15, 2026
grantor/seller Estate Of Cynthia Nicholas; Reeves, Heir At Law, Diane M
grantee/buyer 135 Street Investors LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$285,000
May 15, 2026
mortgagor/borrower 135 Street Investors LLC
mortgagee/lender Domi Capital LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
$10
May 15, 2026
grantor/seller Estate Of Cynthia Nicholas; Heir At Law, Derek Nicholas To His Interest +1
grantee/buyer 135 Street Investors LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$190,000
May 15, 2026
mortgagor/borrower 135 Street Investors LLC
mortgagee/lender Domi Capital LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Mar 8, 2017
assignor/old lender Cit Bank Na; One West Bank Na +1
assignee/new lender Secretary Of Housing And Urban Development
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Aug 15, 2016
assignor/old lender Financial Freedom Acquisition LLC; Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems Inc +1
assignee/new lender Onewest Bank Fsb
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Dec 4, 2013
assignor/old lender Financial Freedom; Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems Inc +1
assignee/new lender Onewest Bank Fsb
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$675,000
Mar 15, 2010
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Financial Freedom Acquisition LLC; Mers, Inc.
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$675,000
Mar 15, 2010
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Secretary Of Housing And Urban Development
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Nov 24, 2009
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Chynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Secretary Of Hud
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Nov 18, 2009
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Financial Freedom Senior Funding Corporation
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Oct 8, 2009
assignor/old lender Financial Freedom Senior Funding Corporation
assignee/new lender Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems, Inc
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Mar 26, 2008
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Chase Home Finance LLC
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$544,185
Mar 18, 2008
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Financial Freedom Senior Funding Corporation
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$544,185
Mar 18, 2008
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Secretary Of Housing And Urban Development
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jan 26, 2005
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Ford Consumer Finance Company, Inc.
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Jan 26, 2005
assignor/old lender Citifinancial Mortgage Company Inc Fka Associates; Home Equity Services, Inc.
assignee/new lender Charter One Mortgage Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jan 3, 2002
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Fitzroy; Nichols, Cynthia
mortgagee/lender Ford Consumer Finance Company Inc
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Jan 3, 2002
assignor/old lender Associates Home Equity Services Inc; Ford Consumer Finance Company Inc
assignee/new lender Equity One Credit Corporation
View on ACRIS ↗
POWER OF ATTORNEY
Oct 26, 2000
party one Fitzroy, Nicholas D
party two Nicholas, Cynthia
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Oct 26, 2000
assignor/old lender Concord Mortgage Corp
assignee/new lender Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$204,500
Oct 26, 2000
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Concord Mortgage Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
May 29, 1997
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Norstar Mortgage Corporation
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$179,179
May 6, 1997
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Ford Consumer Finance Co. Inc.
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Mar 27, 1991
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Intercounty Mtgee Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Mar 30, 1989
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Empbanque Capital Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Jan 18, 1989
mortgager/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Intercounty Mtgee Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$163,000
Dec 8, 1988
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Norstar Mtge Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Nov 20, 1987
assignor/old lender Intercounty Mtgee Corp
assignee/new lender Federal Home Loan Mtg Cp
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$101,000
Dec 24, 1986
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Empbanque Capital Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
SATISFACTION OF MORTGAGE
Oct 29, 1984
mortgager/borrower Chisholm, Cynthia; Nembhard, Derrick +1
mortgagee/lender Greater N Y Savs Bank
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Aug 8, 1984
grantor/seller Nembhard, Derrick D; Nembhard, Phillis
grantee/buyer Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
$87,000
Aug 8, 1984
mortgagor/borrower Nicholas, Cynthia; Nicholas, Fitzroy
mortgagee/lender Intercounty Mtgee Corp
View on ACRIS ↗
ASSIGNMENT, MORTGAGE
Dec 30, 1982
assignor/old lender Greater New York Savs Bk
assignee/new lender State/New York Mtgeagcy
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Nov 5, 1981
grantor/seller Chisholm Cynthia; Nembhard Derrick D +1
grantee/buyer Nembhard Derrick D; Nembhard Phyllis
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Feb 13, 1981
grantor/seller Milazzo Girolamo G; Milazzo Sherry +1
grantee/buyer Chisholm Cynthia; Nembhard Derrick +1
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
Feb 13, 1981
mortgagor/borrower Chissholn Cynthia; Nembhard Derrick +1
mortgagee/lender Greater New York Savings Bank
View on ACRIS ↗
DEED
Oct 10, 1978
grantor/seller Hershkowitz Helen; Hershkowitz Sam
grantee/buyer Milazzo Girolamo G; Milazzo Sherry
View on ACRIS ↗
MORTGAGE
Oct 10, 1978
mortgagor/borrower Milazzo Girolamo G; Milazzo Sherry
mortgagee/lender Banker Trust Company
View on ACRIS ↗DOB complaints — total 1 · open 0 · closed 1
Certificate of occupancy – none/illegal/contrary
Closed
Oct 22, 2004
Complaint 3143203
View on BIS ↗No DOB violations or HPD violations on file.
Deed & identifiers
SBL3077760047
SWIS610100
Parcel ID6101003077760047
Who owns 5024 Avenue I?
5024 Avenue I, Brooklyn is owned by Cynthia Nicholas per the 2025 NYS assessment roll. It last sold for $190,000 in Apr 2026.
Nearby on Avenue I
Public record, NYS tax roll 2025. Values are the assessor's, not an appraisal. Provided for informational purposes only — accuracy and completeness are not warranted or guaranteed; verify against official sources before relying on it. Disclaimer · Request redaction
Search by name or address · Browse all records